The Times-Union selects its annual All-First Coast team for high school girls soccer across Jacksonville and Northeast Florida for the 2025-26 season.
First team
G Alyvia Bishop, Sr., St. Johns Country Day
Reliable senior recorded 14 shutouts against elite schedule for Class 1A semifinalists; committed to Pensacola State College.
D Kate Bachman, So., Beachside
Solidified defense for improving Barracudas and also scored two goals.
D Lulu Consunji, Jr., Ponte Vedra
Superbly composed in central defense, organizing the attacking buildup and netting 10 goals; on course for UCF.
D Emma Dresback, Sr., Creekside
Auburn-Montgomery commit scored three times and helped Knights limit opponents to 12 goals all year.
WB Kate Kirby, Sr., Bartram Trail
Overlapping threat along right flank for Bears, scoring five goals and six assists; powerful shot from distance.
M Stella Jones, Sr., Bishop Kenny
Scored from every angle for Class 4A finalist Crusaders with 21 goals, 20 assists; constantly-active midfielder signed with Navy.
M Camila Adame, Jr., Creekside
Accurate passer anchored Knights midfield, scoring nine goals; committed to Texas Tech and on course for Women’s World Cup soccer with Puerto Rico.
WB Cate Petre, Sr., Bishop Kenny
Wingback never slowed down for BK with 15 goals, 15 assists; signed with Sam Houston State.
F Victoria Sarka, Sr., St. Johns Country Day
Trevecca Nazarene signee was constant force on right wing, scoring 32 goals and 11 assists.
F Lily Morse, Sr., Ponte Vedra
Primary attacking threat for regional finalist Sharks tallied 17 goals, eight assists; committed to Dartmouth after netting 64 career Ponte Vedra goals.
F Layla Davis, Jr., Bartram Trail
Breakout star for Bears this year had too much speed for defenders, netting 20 goals.
Second team
G Abby Kennedy, Jr., Ponte Vedra
D Sascha Brooks, So., Atlantic Coast
D Mia Lieb, Sr., Bolles
D Avery Suvoski, Jr., Bolles
M Calli Berrang, Sr., St. Johns Country Day
M Jaclyn Bessman, Sr., Creekside
M Bella Duenas, Sr., Beachside
M Savannah Hartford, Sr., Creekside
F Shea Donovan, Fr., Bishop Kenny
F Bella Rutherford, Sr., Mandarin
F Kendall Trimiar, Jr., Providence
Third team
G Alannah Zander, Sr., Beachside
D Charlotte Andrus, Sr., Clay
D Ava McLaughlin, Sr., Bartram Trail
D Anna Perry, Sr., Bishop Kenny
M Charlotte Martin, So., Ponte Vedra
M Alana Mantello, So., St. Johns Country Day
M Grace Raymond, Jr., Ponte Vedra
M Lila Ranalli, Jr., Episcopal
F Rylie Gardner, Sr., Fleming Island
F Alana Hornberger, So., Nease
F Millie Vieczorek, Fr., St. Joseph
Honorable mention
F Sy’Ayerra Agusta, Sr., Riverside; M Belle Alford, Jr., St. Joseph; F Kendyl Banks, Sr., Oakleaf; M Madyson Bauman, Sr., St. Johns Country Day; D Bria Bedway, Fr., Bartram Trail; M Sarah Benjamin, Sr., Fernandina Beach; F Lakyn Boyer, So., Tocoi Creek; D Chloe Chandler, So., Ponte Vedra; G Ryann Clowers, Sr., Fletcher; D Katherine Cobos, Sr., Wolfson; M Layla Cummings, So., St. Augustine; M Katie Cunningham, Jr., Providence; M Sienna Dancel, Sr., Fletcher; D Abrianna Delgatti, Fr., Bishop Kenny; D Logan Griffin, Sr., Creekside; F Alaira Handy, Sr., Suwannee; M Lila Kassel, Fr., Mandarin; M Avery Kelly, So., Menendez; G Gabby Keyser, Sr., Tocoi Creek; M Charleston Knight, Sr., Fernandina Beach; F Karter Koon, Jr., Baker County; M Halea Lam, Sr., Keystone Heights; F Ellie Larkin, So., Nease; M McKenna Lukanich, Sr., Tocoi Creek; D Bella Malhatra, Fr., Bolles; M Ariel Najera, Sr., Yulee; M Ruby Owen, Sr., Middleburg; G Cora Parker, Sr., Clay; M Miller Pickett, So., Wolfson; F Rachel Samilian, Fr., Christ’s Church; D Maddie Smith, Sr., Episcopal; F Parker Smith, Jr., Beachside; F Maddie Tight, Jr., Episcopal; M Ava Touchton, Sr., Stanton; M Kendall Underwood, Fr., Bartram Trail; F Anastasia Virata, Sr., Fletcher; G Anna Wages, Sr., Orange Park; F Tatum Waugh, Jr., Clay
Note: The Times-Union evaluates numerous factors in selecting the All-First Coast teams, including nominations from coaches, observations from the Times-Union sports staff, statistical performances and strength of opposition.
(This story has been updated to add a photo or video.)
This article originally appeared on Florida Times-Union: All-First Coast: Meet the 2025-26 team for high school girls soccer
Reporting by Clayton Freeman, Jacksonville Florida Times-Union / Florida Times-Union
USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect
