A day after a commotion led to dozens of prospective jurors dismissed from service during a murder trial, Lee Circuit Judge Nicholas Thompson has warned two families to stay apart.
Thompson, presiding over the murder trial in the slaying of 15-year-old Kayla Rincon-Miller after at least one juror witnessed a tense interaction between the families of two teens accused.
Thomas Stein, 18, of North Fort Myers, faces charges of first-degree murder and attempted armed robbery. His trial, which began April 27 with jury selection, is expected to last through May 1.
During the lunch break on the first day of trial, Stein’s family clashed with the family of Christopher Horne Jr., 18, the other teen arrested in the case.
“Ladies and gentlemen, your jury service is complete for the rest of the year,” Thompson told about 50 potential jurors. “I’m going to release all of you.”
Tuesday morning, as the trial resumed, Thompson said the families are ordered to refrain from engaging with each other to avoid any more conflicts/confrontations
Jury selection will restart April 28 with a new pool of jurors.
Stein walked into the courtroom dressed in a black suit and tie.
Throughout the first day of his trial, Thomas Stein looked back at the gallery looking for family and friends sitting off to the left but did not wave or smile, compared to past court hearings.
To the right, Rincon-Miller’s mother, Luz Rincon, sat with her relatives. She gasped and wiped tears more than once, at one point having to briefly leave the courtroom accompanied by a victim’s advocate from the State Attorney’s Office.
Assistant State Attorney Sara Miller, who is prosecuting the case along with Assistant State Attorney Alyssa Wolf, said the defense attempted to offer a plea, but the state rejected it, citing low standards.
Stein is not expected to have witnesses testify on his behalf.
Twelve jurors and two alternates will make up the jury. The attorneys began screening 50 potential jurors on April 27.
The other teen arrested in the case, Horne, of Cape Coral, on Sept. 19, 2025, pleaded no contest to second-degree murder in the death of Rincon-Miller.
Prosecutors and Stein’s attorneys collected Horne’s testimony during an April 2 deposition, according to court filings. His sentence will depend on the honesty of his testimony, but it is expected to be 25 years in prison and is set for May 19.
While police reports have stated Stein was not the shooter, Miller on April 27 said in court that as part of Stein’s guilt, jurors will have to determine if the accused teen fired a weapon that spring break night in March 2024.
How did SW Florida authorities connect the teens to the murder?
Cape Coral Police arrested the younger Horne weeks after they arrested Stein in Rincon-Miller’s March 17, 2024, death.
A grand jury indicted each suspect on one count of first-degree murder and three counts of attempted robbery, both including the use of a firearm.
A detailed Cape Coral Police report also indicates Stein was not the shooter and says a third suspect accompanied Horne and Stein.
Police have not released information on a third suspect and court documents have not reversed authorities’ theory as Stein’s and Horne’s cases moved through the courts.
Rincon-Miller was walking with two friends from the movie theater at 2323 Del Prado Blvd. S., to a nearby McDonald’s.
As they approached Southeast 20th Street, court documents say, a “fancy” silver SUV blinded them with the high beams and several males exited the SUV.
Two of them waved firearms and demanded the girls give them their bags, police said. One of Rincon-Miller’s two friends told authorities she heard three gunshots and realized Rincon-Miller had been shot.
One of Rincon-Miller’s friends is expected to testify accompanied by a support kitten.
Tomas Rodriguez is a Breaking/Live News Reporter for the Naples Daily News and The News-Press. You can reach Tomas at TRodriguez@usatodayco.com or 772-333-5501. Connect with him on Threads @tomasfrobeltran, Instagram @tomasfrobeltran, Facebook @tomasrodrigueznews and Bluesky @tomasfrodriguez.
This article originally appeared on Fort Myers News-Press: Commotion between families restarts jury selection in murder trial
Reporting by Tomas Rodriguez, Fort Myers News-Press & Naples Daily News / Fort Myers News-Press
USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect
