Lee County School Superintendent Denise Carlin defended a sweeping “strategic budget realignment” as the district faces a projected $92.4 million deficit.
During a press conference at the Lee County School District headquarters Friday, May 1, Carlin said the district is moving away from “legacy spending” that created a $35 million gap in allocations that did not match current student enrollment or needs.
Carlin told the media that her administration has already cut nearly $16 million from district-level departments, with another $6.5 million in reductions proposed for the next fiscal year.
“I want to be very clear about what we are doing. We are restoring fiscal discipline, cutting waste and putting the focus back where it belongs on students and classrooms,” Carlin said. She argued that for years, funding had drifted away from direct instruction into administrative bureaucracy.
The School District of Lee County has not yet shared specific cuts by school with The News-Press & Naples Daily News, but district spokespeople said they expect those numbers to be available around mid-May.
Carlin stood alongside Florida Education Commissioner Anastasios Kamoutsas, who supported the district and described Carlin’s approach as a model for the rest of the state.
“Superintendent Carlin has also shown fiscal responsibility. Upon taking office, she made the tough but necessary decision to reduce spending at the district level, protecting resources for the classroom. And now, as new financial challenges arise, she is continuing the disciplined approach by streamlining district leadership and reducing administrative overhead,” Kamoutsas said.
Protesters gathered outside, barred from press conference
While district officials spoke inside the school board chamber, a small group of protesters gathered outside in the nearly 90-degree heat, continuing the momentum from a much larger demonstration held Wednesday, April 29.
The news conference was available for media only, causing some tense moments at the entrance of the district building. Some community members, including former school board members, were turned away and told they could not attend the conference.
Outside, the group of about nine former teachers, parents and other community members continued to voice frustration over what they described as a lack of transparency regarding teacher non-renewals and the future of specialized student programs.
Inside, Carlin acknowledged the presence of the protesters by reiterating her campaign promises. “When I ran for this office, I made a commitment to the residents and taxpayers of Lee County that I would scrutinize every single dollar in how it is spent. I am not going to apologize for doing what the voters hired me to do,” she told reporters.
How will teachers and classroom sizes be affected?
The Lee County School District has started issuing preliminary notices to staff that their contracts may not be renewed as part of the budget realignment.
While the district avoids using the term “layoffs,” union leaders say the number of non‑renewals at certain schools is substantial.
“As we are realigning our school budgets to match state funding, yes there have been staff that have been told their contract will not be renewed; those notices are preliminary per their contract they are employed through June 30th,” district spokesperson Riley Kempton wrote in an email to The News-Press & Naples Daily News.
Carlin said that principals were directed to build school-level budgets based on the actual number of students expected in the fall.
When asked about the impact on teachers, she said, “I’m not about cutting classroom teachers just to cut classroom teachers. That’s not what we’re doing. We are giving the schools a budget based on the student enrollment that they are going to have in the fall, and then they will start those schools in accordance with a priority of student achievement. Those are the directions that I’ve given to the principals”.
However, Teachers Association of Lee County (TALC) President Kevin Daly noted that the timing of these decisions is stressful because the state has not yet finalized its own budget.
“We have been seeing the fallout from that over the past week and a half,” Daly told The News-Press & Naples Daily News April 21. “Schools have kind of gotten their preliminary budget, and they’re having to kind of make decisions to fit in their budget.”
The district has maintained that families should not expect changes to class sizes despite the staffing adjustments. Carlin noted that she holds the final veto pen.
“I will go through each one to ensure that our district priorities are met, that critical programs, including, and let me be clear, arts and athletics, remain part of a well-rounded education for our students, and that wasteful spending is eliminated,” Carlin said.
What’s causing budget cuts?
The district has attributed the projected $46.7 million deficit to a combination of rising costs and declining enrollment. It points to declining enrollment, inflation and the expansion of state school choice programs.
Because state funding follows the student, the district loses revenue when children leave for private or home school options.
The district lost roughly 800 students since last fiscal year. Carlin pushed back on the idea that enrollment decline is the sole driver of the cuts.
“I will certainly agree with you that losing 14 students or 12 students or whatever does not translate into $92 million, but I have never said, and I want to be clear on this, that that is the only reason. We have multiple factors, including the overspending that has occurred in the school district,” Carlin explained.
She pointed to what she described as years of “legacy spending” and administrative overspending, adding that the district had moved away from fiscal discipline well before the current budget cycle.
Carlin said the district identified roughly $35 million in overallocations to schools that were not tied to current enrollment or student need, but instead reflected funding decisions based on “how things have always been done.”
“When I cannot account for why $35 million was given out randomly to our schools, that’s a problem,” she said. “Over time, legacy spending created a $35 million gap in allocations that were not tied to current student needs or enrollment. This is what I am correcting.”
To help offset the gap, the district plans to reduce its reliance on roughly $45.4 million in capital fund transfers used to support general operating costs. The district describes this as a “sustainability mindset,” meant to eliminate non-essential spending to protect teacher investments and the classroom environment.
Carlin added that her administration has already cut nearly $16 million from district-level departments, and proposed another $6.5 million in reductions for the next fiscal year.
Going forward, she said schools will be funded strictly based on their enrollment, similar to a charter-school model.
The school district is currently awaiting the final state budget before the proposed realignment plans are fully implemented. Protesters have vowed to continue their advocacy at the next school board meeting May 12.
Do you have an opinion about this topic? Write a letter to the editor and send it to letters@naplesnews.com and/or mailbag@news-press.com. Keep it to 250 words or fewer and include your contact info. Have more to say: Send a guest column of no more than 600 words.
Mickenzie Hannon is a watchdog reporter for The News-Press and Naples Daily News, covering Collier and Lee counties. Contact her at 239-435-3423 or mhannon@gannett.com.
Please support local community journalism and stay informed about Southwest Florida news by subscribing to The News-Press and Naples Daily News; download the free News-Press or Naples Daily News app, and sign up for daily briefing email newsletter, food & dining and growth & development newsletters here and here.
This article originally appeared on Fort Myers News-Press: ‘Not going to apologize’: Lee County superintendent defends budget cuts
Reporting by Mickenzie Hannon, Fort Myers News-Press & Naples Daily News / Fort Myers News-Press
USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect
